Free sample · about 35 minutes

Does Jesus Exist?

The Preface, the Introduction, and Chapter 12, “Witnesses Outside the Bible”: what Roman, Jewish and Greek writers said about Jesus. Read it here, free, with no sign-up.

Preface

I have written this book because I wanted to know.

Not to know about the arguments — there are already shelves full of those — but to know whether the story I had grown up hearing would still stand once I followed it back to the stones, the scrolls, and the clay tablets on which it was first recorded. I wanted to know whether the rivers of Eden could be found on a map, whether the kings of Israel had left their names anywhere outside the Bible, whether Roman historians who despised Christianity nevertheless admitted that Christ had lived and died. Most of all I wanted to know whether the answer to the question on the cover of this book is yes.

The title is deliberately in the present tense. A historian can ask, “Did Jesus exist?” and the answer to that question — as we shall see — is about as certain as anything in ancient history ever gets. But the Christian faith has always made a stronger claim: that the man who was crucified under Pontius Pilate rose from the dead and is alive today. “I am he that liveth, and was dead,” he says in the final book of the Bible, “and, behold, I am alive for evermore” (Revelation 1:18). That is why the question is not “Did Jesus exist?” but “Does Jesus exist?” The first is a question for the archive. The second is a question for every one of us.

This book follows the order of the Bible itself. It begins where Scripture begins, with the creation of the world and the garden planted “eastward in Eden,” and it ends where the Gospels end, at a tomb that was found empty on the first day of the week. Along the way we will examine how the books of the Bible were gathered and preserved, what archaeology has uncovered about the patriarchs and kings, how the genealogy of Jesus was recorded and guarded, which prophecies were written centuries before his birth, and what pagan and Jewish writers of the first and second centuries said about him — often with open hostility.

I have tried to write as a careful witness rather than a salesman. Where the evidence is strong, I say so plainly. Where Christians themselves disagree — the age of the earth is the most obvious example — I set out the positions honestly and tell you which way I lean and why. Where a claimed discovery has not held up under examination, I tell you that too. A case for the truth does not need to be propped up with exaggerations, and readers who are skeptical deserve to see that the believer has looked at the hard questions as squarely as they have.

Every historical claim in this book is tied to a source you can check for yourself. Ancient writers are cited by their standard book-and-section numbers, so that you can find the passage in any edition or translation. Modern scholarship is cited by author and year, and every work cited is listed in full in the References at the back. I would be delighted if this book sent you off to read Josephus, Tacitus, and the Dead Sea Scrolls for yourself.

If you come to these pages as a believer, I hope they strengthen your confidence that your faith rests on events that really happened, in real places, under real rulers whose names are carved in stone. If you come as a skeptic, I ask only that you weigh the evidence with the same fairness you would give to any other question of ancient history. And if you come somewhere in between — curious, searching, unsure — then this book was written especially for you.

Riekus Van Der Westhuizen
2026

Introduction: The Question That Will Not Go Away

Some questions fade with time. Others grow louder. For two thousand years one question has refused to leave the human conversation: Who was Jesus of Nazareth, and is any of it true?

It has been asked by emperors and fishermen, by philosophers in Athens and peasants in Galilee, by Roman governors and Jewish rabbis, by medieval monks and modern scientists. In the second century a Greek philosopher named Celsus wrote an entire book attacking the Christians, and the Christian scholar Origen wrote an even longer book answering him. In the nineteenth century European critics tried to strip the Gospels down to a bare human outline, and in the twentieth a handful of writers went further still and argued that Jesus had never lived at all. Today the question is typed into search engines millions of times a year: Did Jesus really exist?

This book sets out to answer that question by the same methods we use to answer any question about the ancient world. It asks what documents survive, how old they are, who wrote them, and whether they have been faithfully copied. It asks what archaeologists have found in the ground — inscriptions, coins, seals, buildings, tombs — and whether those finds agree with the written record. It asks what neighbours, enemies, and outsiders said, since the testimony of a hostile witness carries special weight. And it asks whether the best explanation of all this evidence is that the events described in the Bible really happened.

How Historians Know Anything

Before we begin, it is worth pausing over a simple point that is often forgotten: nothing in ancient history can be proved in the way a theorem is proved in mathematics or a reaction is demonstrated in a laboratory. We cannot rerun the Battle of Marathon or interview Julius Caesar. Every statement we make about the ancient world rests on surviving evidence — usually fragmentary, often late, sometimes biased — and on our judgment about how best to explain it.

Historians therefore speak in terms of probability and of the best explanation. When we say that Alexander the Great conquered Persia, or that Hannibal crossed the Alps with elephants, we mean that the surviving evidence is best explained by those events having happened. Our confidence depends on a set of well-established questions:

  • How early is the evidence? A source written within living memory of an event is generally more reliable than one written centuries later.
  • How many independent sources are there? When several witnesses who did not copy one another agree on a fact, our confidence rises sharply.
  • Is the testimony embarrassing to the person giving it? People rarely invent details that hurt their own cause. Historians call this the criterion of embarrassment.
  • Does hostile testimony confirm it? When an enemy concedes a fact, it is very unlikely to have been invented by friends.
  • Does archaeology fit the story? Names, places, customs, coins, and buildings described in a text can often be checked against what is found in the ground.
  • Has the text been faithfully transmitted? We need to know that the words we read today are substantially the words that were first written.

These are not special rules invented to help Christianity. They are the ordinary tools of every working historian, and in the chapters that follow we will apply them to the Bible with no special favours.

It is also worth remembering that “absence of evidence” behaves differently in ancient history than many people assume. The overwhelming majority of what was written in antiquity has been lost. Of the 142 books of Livy’s history of Rome, only 35 survive. Of Tacitus’s Histories, which once covered the years AD 69 to 96, we have only the first four books and part of the fifth. Whole libraries burned; papyrus rotted; parchment was scraped clean and reused. When someone says, “If Jesus really existed, why didn’t more Roman writers mention him?”, the honest answer begins with the observation that we have lost most of what Roman writers wrote — and that a crucified provincial teacher from Galilee was, from Rome’s point of view, a very small figure indeed. As we shall see, it is remarkable how much we have, not how little.

What This Book Is — and Is Not

This book is written from a Christian point of view, and I make no secret of it. I believe that Jesus of Nazareth is the Son of God, that he died for our sins and rose again, and that he is alive today. But a Christian point of view is not the same thing as a careless one. Precisely because I believe these things are true, I am not interested in defending them with weak arguments, inflated claims, or “discoveries” that cannot bear scrutiny. Truth has nothing to fear from careful investigation.

For that reason you will find in these pages three kinds of evidence, and I have tried to label them clearly:

  1. Evidence that virtually all historians accept, whether Christian or not — for example, that Jesus was a Jewish teacher from Galilee who was crucified in Judea under Pontius Pilate. On these points the Christian and the skeptical historian stand on common ground.
  2. Evidence that is strong but debated — for example, the dating of certain biblical books or the interpretation of particular inscriptions. Here I give the main positions and explain why I find one more persuasive.
  3. Claims that are popular but uncertain or unproven — for example, some reported sightings of Noah’s Ark. These I examine honestly, explaining what has been claimed and what the evidence actually shows.

I believe this approach makes the overall case stronger, not weaker. A skeptical reader who discovers that an author has overstated one point will rightly distrust the rest. A reader who sees that the author has been scrupulously fair will be far more willing to follow the argument where it leads.

The Shape of the Journey

The book follows the storyline of the Bible from beginning to end, because the Christian claim about Jesus does not float free of history. The New Testament presents Jesus as the son of David, the son of Abraham, and ultimately the son of Adam (Matthew 1:1; Luke 3:38). It presents him as the fulfilment of promises made to Israel over many centuries. If the story of Israel is fiction, the claims made about Jesus lose their foundation; if the story of Israel is rooted in real history, those claims gain a context that makes sense of them.

  • Chapters 1 and 2 ask how the Bible came to be the collection of books we have today, and whether its text has been reliably preserved across the centuries.
  • Chapters 3 through 5 go back to the very beginning: the Garden of Eden and its rivers, the age of the earth according to the biblical chronology, and the great Flood of Noah’s day with the ancient traditions that surround the mountains of Ararat.
  • Chapters 6 through 8 trace the patriarchs, the Exodus, the kings of Israel and Judah, and the exile to Babylon, comparing the biblical account with the inscriptions and archaeology of Egypt, Assyria, Babylon, and Persia.
  • Chapters 9 and 10 examine the genealogy of Jesus and the prophecies concerning the coming Messiah, many of them preserved in manuscripts copied before he was born.
  • Chapters 11 through 13 turn to the first century: the archaeology of the world Jesus walked, the Roman, Jewish, and Greek writers who mentioned him, and the way he is remembered in the scriptures of other faiths.
  • Chapters 14 through 16 examine the Gospels as historical documents, the evidence for the crucifixion and resurrection, and the explosive growth of a church that no empire could stop.
  • The Conclusion gathers the threads and returns to the question on the cover.

At the back of the book you will find a timeline, a table of the most important archaeological discoveries, the full text of the principal non-Christian references to Jesus, and a complete list of references.

A Note on Sources and Conventions

Scripture. Unless otherwise noted, quotations from the Bible are from the King James Version, chosen because it is in the public domain and because its language has shaped the English-speaking world’s memory of these texts for four centuries. Where the KJV’s older English might obscure the meaning, I explain it in the text.

Ancient authors. Ancient works are cited by their traditional divisions — book, chapter, and section — which are the same in every edition. Thus Annals 15.44 refers to the forty-fourth chapter of the fifteenth book of Tacitus’s Annals, and Antiquities 18.63 refers to section 63 of the eighteenth book of Josephus’s Antiquities of the Jews. English translations are taken from older public-domain editions (listed in the References) or are my own.

Modern works. Modern scholarship is cited by the author’s surname and year of publication — for example, (Metzger 1987) — and full details appear in the References.

Dates. Dates are given as BC (“before Christ”) and AD (anno Domini, “in the year of the Lord”). Dates before about 1000 BC are approximate, and where specialists disagree I say so.

Abbreviations. A few abbreviations recur often:

  • Ant. — Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews
  • War — Josephus, The Jewish War
  • HE — Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History (Historia Ecclesiastica)
  • KJV — King James Version
  • LXX — the Septuagint, the ancient Greek translation of the Hebrew Scriptures
  • DSS — the Dead Sea Scrolls

With that, let us begin — not in Bethlehem, but where the Bible itself begins, with a question every reader must face before opening it at all: How did these particular books come to be gathered into one?

Chapter 12 — Witnesses Outside the Bible: Roman, Jewish, and Greek Sources

Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus.

— Tacitus, Annals 15.44

Suppose for a moment that the New Testament had never been written, or that every copy of it had perished. Would we know anything about Jesus of Nazareth?

The answer is yes. Even without a single Christian document, we would know from Roman, Jewish, and Greek writers of the first and second centuries that a man named Jesus, called Christ, lived in Judea in the time of the Emperor Tiberius; that he had a reputation as a wise man and a worker of extraordinary deeds; that he had a brother named James; that he was executed by crucifixion under the Roman governor Pontius Pilate; that his followers claimed he had appeared to them alive after his death; and that within a few decades they had spread across the Roman Empire, worshipping him as a god and willing to die rather than deny him.

What makes this testimony so valuable is that it comes from people who had no reason to invent it. Several of these writers despised Christianity. Others regarded it as a curious foreign superstition. None of them was trying to promote faith in Jesus. When witnesses like these confirm the basic facts of the Gospel story, historians give their testimony special weight.

In this chapter we will examine each of the major sources in turn, consider honestly the questions scholars have raised about them, and then draw together what they tell us. The full texts of the most important passages are given in Appendix C.

Flavius Josephus: The Jewish Historian

The most important non-Christian witness to Jesus is the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus, whom we have already met many times in this book.

Josephus was born in Jerusalem in AD 37 or 38, just a few years after the crucifixion, to an aristocratic priestly family. He received a thorough education in Jewish law and, as a young man, spent time with each of the main Jewish religious parties. When the Jewish revolt against Rome broke out in AD 66, he was appointed commander of the rebel forces in Galilee. Captured by the Romans after the siege of Jotapata in AD 67, he won the favour of the Roman general Vespasian by predicting that he would become emperor — a prediction fulfilled two years later. Josephus spent the rest of his life in Rome under the patronage of the Flavian emperors, whose family name he took, and wrote several major works: The Jewish War (c. AD 75), Antiquities of the Jews (c. AD 93–94), his autobiography (Life), and Against Apion.

Josephus was not a Christian. He was a Jew who had made his peace with Rome, and he wrote for a Roman audience to explain and defend Jewish history and religion. He grew up in Jerusalem in the decades immediately after Jesus’ death, when Jesus’ brother James was the leader of the Christian community there. He was in a position to know a great deal.

In the Antiquities, Josephus mentions Jesus twice, and also gives an account of John the Baptist.

The Brother of Jesus (Antiquities 20.200)

The shorter of the two references to Jesus is the less disputed, so it is the best place to start. In Book 20 of the Antiquities, Josephus describes events in Jerusalem in AD 62. The Roman governor Festus (known from Acts 24–26) had died in office, and his successor Albinus had not yet arrived. During this interval, the high priest Ananus — a son of the Annas who appears in the Gospels — took advantage of the absence of Roman authority:

Festus was now dead, and Albinus was but upon the road; so he assembled the sanhedrim of judges, and brought before them the brother of Jesus, who was called Christ, whose name was James, and some others; and when he had formed an accusation against them as breakers of the law, he delivered them to be stoned.

— Josephus, Antiquities 20.200 (Whiston translation)

Josephus goes on to say that the most fair-minded citizens of Jerusalem were offended by this action and complained to King Agrippa II and to Albinus, with the result that Ananus was removed from the high priesthood after only three months.

This passage is accepted as authentic by the overwhelming majority of scholars, Christian and non-Christian alike (Meier 1991; Van Voorst 2000). It appears in all the manuscripts of the Antiquities. It fits naturally into its context, which is about Ananus, not about Jesus or James. Its wording is not what a Christian forger would have written: a Christian would have called James “the brother of the Lord,” as Paul does (Galatians 1:19), not “the brother of Jesus, who was called Christ.” And the passage is quoted by the Christian scholar Origen in the third century (Against Celsus 1.47).

The passage tells us several important things. It confirms that Jesus had a brother named James, as the New Testament says (Mark 6:3; Galatians 1:19). It confirms that Jesus was known as “Christ” — that is, that his followers claimed he was the Messiah. And it confirms that James was a significant enough figure in Jerusalem to be singled out for execution by the high priest. Notice also that Josephus identifies James by his relationship to Jesus, assuming that his readers already know who Jesus is — which suggests that Josephus had mentioned Jesus earlier in his work.

The Testimonium Flavianum (Antiquities 18.63–64)

He had. In Book 18 of the Antiquities, in the middle of his account of Pontius Pilate’s governorship, Josephus includes a paragraph about Jesus that has become known as the Testimonium Flavianum, the “testimony of Flavius.” In the form preserved in all surviving Greek manuscripts, it reads:

Now there was about this time Jesus, a wise man, if it be lawful to call him a man; for he was a doer of wonderful works, a teacher of such men as receive the truth with pleasure. He drew over to him both many of the Jews and many of the Gentiles. He was [the] Christ. And when Pilate, at the suggestion of the principal men amongst us, had condemned him to the cross, those that loved him at the first did not forsake him; for he appeared to them alive again the third day; as the divine prophets had foretold these and ten thousand other wonderful things concerning him. And the tribe of Christians, so named from him, are not extinct at this day.

— Josephus, Antiquities 18.63–64 (Whiston translation)

This passage has been debated more intensely than almost any other paragraph in ancient literature, and an honest account must explain why.

The problem is that some phrases in it sound as if they were written by a Christian. Would Josephus, a devout Jew who never became a Christian, really have written “if it be lawful to call him a man,” or flatly declared “He was the Christ,” or affirmed that “he appeared to them alive again the third day; as the divine prophets had foretold”? The third-century Christian scholar Origen, who knew the works of Josephus well, states twice that Josephus “did not believe in Jesus as the Christ” (Against Celsus 1.47; Commentary on Matthew 10.17) — which suggests that the copy of Josephus Origen read did not contain the words “He was the Christ.”

Scholars have therefore taken three main positions:

  1. Entirely authentic. A small minority hold that Josephus wrote the whole passage as it stands, perhaps ironically or reporting what Christians believed.
  2. Entirely forged. Another minority hold that the whole passage was inserted by a Christian copyist.
  3. Partly authentic. The great majority of scholars today hold that Josephus did write a passage about Jesus at this point, but that a Christian copyist later added a few phrases to it (Meier 1991; Van Voorst 2000).

The third position is supported by several strong arguments. When the most obviously Christian phrases are removed, what remains reads very naturally as the work of Josephus. Its vocabulary is typical of his style and not of early Christian writing: he calls Jesus a “wise man” (sophos anēr), a term he also uses of Solomon and the prophet Daniel; he calls his miracles “surprising deeds” (paradoxa erga), the same expression he uses of the miracles of the prophet Elisha (Antiquities 9.182); and he calls Christians a “tribe” (phylon), a term no Christian would have used of his own community. The statement that Jesus won over “many of the Gentiles” is not something the Gospels emphasize, so a Christian forger would be unlikely to invent it. And the passage blames Jesus’ death primarily on Pilate, mentioning the Jewish leaders only as accusers, which fits Josephus’s own perspective better than that of later Christian writers. Finally, as we have seen, the later reference to “Jesus, who was called Christ” in Antiquities 20.200 makes best sense if Josephus had already introduced Jesus to his readers.

When the probable Christian additions are set aside, the original passage likely read something like this:

About this time there lived Jesus, a wise man. For he was a doer of surprising deeds, a teacher of such people as receive the truth with pleasure. He won over many Jews and many of the Gentiles. And when Pilate, upon an accusation by the leading men among us, had condemned him to the cross, those who had first loved him did not cease to do so. And to this day the tribe of the Christians, named after him, has not disappeared.

The Arabic Version

Support for this reconstruction came from an unexpected source. In 1971 the Israeli scholar Shlomo Pines published a study of a tenth-century history of the world written in Arabic by Agapius, a Christian bishop of Hierapolis in Syria (Pines 1971). Agapius quotes a version of Josephus’s passage about Jesus which differs significantly from the Greek text. In Agapius’s version, Jesus is described as a wise man whose conduct was good and who was known to be virtuous; many people from among the Jews and the other nations became his disciples; Pilate condemned him to be crucified and to die; his disciples did not abandon their discipleship, and they reported that he had appeared to them three days after his crucifixion and that he was alive; “accordingly, he was perhaps the Messiah, concerning whom the prophets have recounted wonders.”

In this version, the most Christian-sounding statements are absent or softened. Jesus is not said to be more than a man; his being the Messiah is presented as a possibility (“perhaps”); and his resurrection appearances are presented as something his disciples reported, not as a fact affirmed by Josephus. Many scholars believe that Agapius’s version, although it has its own difficulties, preserves a form of the passage closer to what Josephus originally wrote.

What Josephus Tells Us

Even on the most cautious reading, Josephus — a Jewish historian born in Jerusalem a few years after the crucifixion — tells us that Jesus:

  • lived in the time of Pontius Pilate;
  • was regarded as a wise man and a teacher;
  • was reputed to have performed surprising or extraordinary deeds;
  • attracted a following among both Jews and Gentiles;
  • was accused by the Jewish leaders and condemned to crucifixion by Pilate;
  • had followers who remained devoted to him after his death, and who (according to the Arabic version) reported that he had appeared to them alive;
  • was called “Christ,” and gave his name to the Christians, who still existed in Josephus’s day;
  • had a brother named James, who was stoned to death in Jerusalem in AD 62.

John the Baptist (Antiquities 18.116–119)

Josephus also describes the ministry and death of John the Baptist, whom the Gospels present as the forerunner of Jesus. Explaining why many Jews believed that a military defeat suffered by Herod Antipas was divine punishment, he writes:

Now some of the Jews thought that the destruction of Herod’s army came from God, and that very justly, as a punishment of what he did against John, that was called the Baptist: for Herod slew him, who was a good man, and commanded the Jews to exercise virtue, both as to righteousness towards one another, and piety towards God, and so to come to baptism.

— Josephus, Antiquities 18.116–117 (Whiston translation)

Josephus adds that Herod feared John’s great influence over the people, imprisoned him in the fortress of Machaerus, east of the Dead Sea, and put him to death there. The authenticity of this passage is almost universally accepted. It differs from the Gospels in emphasis — the Gospels say that Herod executed John because John had condemned his marriage to his brother’s wife Herodias (Mark 6:17–29), while Josephus emphasizes Herod’s fear of an uprising — but the two explanations are entirely compatible, and they agree on the main facts: John was a popular preacher of righteousness who baptized, and he was imprisoned and executed by Herod Antipas.

Cornelius Tacitus: The Roman Historian

Publius Cornelius Tacitus (c. AD 56–120) is generally regarded as the greatest historian of ancient Rome. He was a senator, held the consulship in AD 97, and served as governor of the province of Asia (western Turkey) around AD 112–113. His last and greatest work, the Annals, written around AD 116, covered the history of Rome from the death of Augustus in AD 14 to the death of Nero in AD 68.

In Book 15 of the Annals, Tacitus describes the Great Fire of Rome, which broke out in July of AD 64 and destroyed much of the city. A rumour spread that the Emperor Nero had ordered the fire himself, perhaps to clear land for a new palace. To deflect suspicion, Tacitus says, Nero found scapegoats:

Consequently, to get rid of the report, Nero fastened the guilt and inflicted the most exquisite tortures on a class hated for their abominations, called Christians by the populace. Christus, from whom the name had its origin, suffered the extreme penalty during the reign of Tiberius at the hands of one of our procurators, Pontius Pilatus, and a most mischievous superstition, thus checked for the moment, again broke out not only in Judaea, the first source of the evil, but even in Rome, where all things hideous and shameful from every part of the world find their centre and become popular. Accordingly, an arrest was first made of all who pleaded guilty; then, upon their information, an immense multitude was convicted, not so much of the crime of firing the city, as of hatred against mankind. Mockery of every sort was added to their deaths. Covered with the skins of beasts, they were torn by dogs and perished, or were nailed to crosses, or were doomed to the flames and burnt, to serve as a nightly illumination, when daylight had expired.

— Tacitus, Annals 15.44 (Church and Brodribb translation)

This passage is one of the most important pieces of evidence for Jesus outside the New Testament, and its authenticity is accepted by virtually all scholars. Its Latin style is unmistakably that of Tacitus — compressed, biting, and contemptuous. No Christian would have described his own faith as “a most mischievous superstition” or spoken of Christians as “hated for their abominations.” The passage is found in the manuscript tradition of the Annals, and there is no credible evidence of tampering.

Consider what Tacitus confirms:

  • Christus was the founder of the movement that bore his name.
  • He was executed — “suffered the extreme penalty” (supplicio adfectus) — a phrase that, in the case of a provincial non-citizen condemned by a Roman governor, would normally imply crucifixion.
  • His execution took place during the reign of Tiberius (AD 14–37).
  • It was carried out by Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor.
  • His movement originated in Judea.
  • It was “checked for the moment” by his death — but then “broke out again,” spreading not only in Judea but to Rome itself.
  • By AD 64, about thirty years after the crucifixion, there was “an immense multitude” of Christians in Rome, and they were willing to suffer horrific deaths.

The phrase “checked for the moment… again broke out” is particularly interesting. It describes, from a hostile outsider’s perspective, exactly what the Gospels and Acts describe from the inside: the movement seemed to die with its founder, and then, unaccountably, came back to life with redoubled force. Tacitus does not explain why. The Christians had an explanation, which they proclaimed in Rome and everywhere else: Jesus had risen from the dead.

Where did Tacitus get his information? He was a careful historian who often tells his readers when he is relying on rumour or doubtful reports, and he does not do so here. As a senator and a member of the priestly college of the quindecimviri, which supervised foreign cults in Rome, and as a former governor of Asia, a province with many Christians, he had every opportunity to learn about the movement from official sources. He would certainly not have taken the Christians’ own word about the origins of a “superstition” he despised. His reference to Pilate as a “procurator” (rather than “prefect,” Pilate’s actual title, as we saw in Chapter 11) shows that he was not copying from the Gospels, which call Pilate simply “governor.”

Pliny the Younger: A Governor’s Dilemma

Around AD 111–113, Gaius Plinius Caecilius Secundus, known as Pliny the Younger, was sent by the Emperor Trajan to govern the province of Bithynia and Pontus, on the southern shore of the Black Sea in northern Turkey. Pliny was a close friend of Tacitus, and many of his letters survive. Book 10 of his correspondence contains his official letters to Trajan, asking for advice on the problems of governing his province — and Trajan’s replies.

One of these letters (10.96) concerns the Christians. Pliny explains that people have been brought before him accused of being Christians, and that he is unsure how to deal with them, since he has never been present at a trial of Christians. His procedure so far has been to ask the accused three times whether they are Christians, threatening them with punishment; those who persist, he has executed, since “whatever the nature of their creed,” their “contumacy and inflexible obstinacy” deserve punishment. Those who deny being Christians, he releases if they offer prayers to the Roman gods and to the emperor’s image and curse Christ — “none of which acts, it is said, those who are really Christians can be forced into performing.”

Pliny then describes what he learned about Christian practices from those who said they had once been Christians but had given it up:

They affirmed, however, the whole of their guilt, or their error, was, that they were in the habit of meeting on a certain fixed day before it was light, when they sang in alternate verses a hymn to Christ, as to a god, and bound themselves by a solemn oath, not to any wicked deeds, but never to commit any fraud, theft or adultery, never to falsify their word, nor deny a trust when they should be called upon to deliver it up; after which it was their custom to separate, and then reassemble to partake of food — but food of an ordinary and innocent kind.

— Pliny the Younger, Letters 10.96 (Melmoth translation, revised by Bosanquet)

To get to the truth, Pliny tortured two female slaves who were called “deaconesses” (ministrae), but found “nothing more than depraved and excessive superstition.” He was alarmed by the number of people involved — many people of every age and rank, and of both sexes — not only in the cities but in villages and rural districts. The pagan temples, he says, had been almost deserted, and the sale of sacrificial animals had collapsed — though he hoped his measures were beginning to reverse the trend.

Trajan’s brief reply (10.97) approves Pliny’s general approach. Christians are not to be sought out; if they are accused and convicted, they must be punished, unless they deny being Christians and prove it by worshipping the gods. But anonymous accusations are not to be accepted, Trajan adds, because they set a dangerous precedent and are out of keeping with the spirit of the age.

Pliny’s letter does not discuss the historical Jesus directly. But it is invaluable evidence for early Christianity. It shows that within about eighty years of the crucifixion, in a province far from Judea, Christians were numerous enough in city and countryside to threaten the business of pagan temples; that they met regularly on a fixed day (Sunday) before dawn; that they sang hymns “to Christ, as to a god”; that they were committed to a high moral standard; that they shared a common meal; that women served as leaders called deaconesses; and that many were willing to die rather than curse Christ. The worship of Jesus as divine was not a late development; it was already the established practice of ordinary Christians in Pliny’s day.

Suetonius: Chrestus and the Expulsion From Rome

Gaius Suetonius Tranquillus (c. AD 69–after 122) served as secretary to the Emperor Hadrian, with access to the imperial archives. Around AD 121 he published The Lives of the Caesars, a collection of biographies of Julius Caesar and the first eleven emperors.

In his life of the Emperor Claudius (AD 41–54), Suetonius lists a number of Claudius’s administrative measures, including this:

Since the Jews constantly made disturbances at the instigation of Chrestus, he expelled them from Rome.

— Suetonius, Life of Claudius 25.4 (Rolfe translation)

Most scholars believe that “Chrestus” is a misspelling of “Christus” — an easy confusion, since Chrestus (Greek chrēstos, “useful” or “good”) was a common name, especially among slaves, and in the Greek pronunciation of the time the two words sounded almost the same. Tacitus’s own manuscript appears to show that the popular name for Christians was sometimes spelled Chrestiani. On this reading, Suetonius is reporting — in a garbled form — disturbances in the Jewish community in Rome over the claim that Jesus was the Messiah, which led the emperor to expel Jews from the city.

This expulsion is mentioned in the New Testament. When Paul arrived in Corinth, he met “a certain Jew named Aquila, born in Pontus, lately come from Italy, with his wife Priscilla; (because that Claudius had commanded all Jews to depart from Rome)” (Acts 18:2). The Christian historian Orosius, writing in the fifth century, dates the expulsion to the ninth year of Claudius — AD 49.

It should be acknowledged that some scholars think Suetonius is referring to some other Jewish agitator in Rome named Chrestus. But if, as most believe, the reference is to Christ, it shows that the message about Jesus had reached the Jewish community of Rome within about twenty years of his death, causing enough controversy to come to the emperor’s attention.

In his life of Nero, Suetonius also records, among Nero’s measures, that “punishment was inflicted on the Christians, a class of men given to a new and mischievous superstition” (Life of Nero 16.2).

The Darkness at the Crucifixion: Thallus and Phlegon

The Synoptic Gospels record that during the crucifixion, “from the sixth hour there was darkness over all the land unto the ninth hour” (Matthew 27:45). Two pagan writers appear to have discussed this event.

Thallus

Thallus wrote a history of the eastern Mediterranean world in Greek, in three books. His work has been lost, and his date is uncertain; many scholars place him around AD 50, though some argue for a later date. We know of his comment on the darkness only because it was quoted by the Christian chronologer Julius Africanus around AD 221, in a passage that in turn survives only in the work of the ninth-century Byzantine historian George Syncellus. Africanus writes:

On the whole world there pressed a most fearful darkness; and the rocks were rent by an earthquake, and many places in Judea and other districts were thrown down. This darkness Thallus, in the third book of his History, calls, as appears to me without reason, an eclipse of the sun.

— Julius Africanus, Chronography, fragment 18 (Ante-Nicene Fathers translation)

Africanus objects that a solar eclipse could not have taken place at Passover, which always falls at the full moon, when the moon is on the opposite side of the earth from the sun.

If Thallus wrote around AD 50, his comment would be remarkable: within about twenty years of the crucifixion, a pagan historian felt the need to offer a natural explanation for the darkness that Christians said had accompanied Jesus’ death — which implies that the story of Jesus’ crucifixion was already circulating widely enough to need refuting. Honesty requires adding that we do not have Thallus’s own words, that we are relying on Africanus’s summary of what he said, and that his date is uncertain. The passage should therefore be given modest weight.

Phlegon of Tralles

Phlegon was a freedman of the Emperor Hadrian who wrote a chronicle of world history arranged by Olympiads, published around AD 140. His work, too, survives only in fragments. Julius Africanus reports that “Phlegon records that, in the time of Tiberius Caesar, at full moon, there was a full eclipse of the sun from the sixth hour to the ninth.” The Christian scholar Origen, writing around AD 248, also cites Phlegon:

And with regard to the eclipse in the time of Tiberius Caesar, in whose reign Jesus appears to have been crucified, and the great earthquakes which then took place, Phlegon too, I think, has written in the thirteenth or fourteenth book of his Chronicles.

— Origen, Against Celsus 2.33 (Ante-Nicene Fathers translation)

Origen adds elsewhere that Phlegon, though not a Christian, attributed to Jesus a knowledge of future events and testified that his predictions had been fulfilled (Against Celsus 2.14). Eusebius, in his Chronicle, quotes Phlegon as recording that in the fourth year of the 202nd Olympiad (AD 32/33) there was a great eclipse of the sun, so that it became night at the sixth hour and stars appeared in the sky, and that a great earthquake in Bithynia toppled many buildings in Nicaea.

As with Thallus, we have Phlegon’s words only at second hand, and his “eclipse” may have been a natural event that Christians later connected with the crucifixion. But the testimony of Phlegon, as reported by Origen, shows at least that a second-century pagan chronicler discussed Jesus and his predictions.

Mara bar Serapion: The Wise King

In the British Library is a Syriac manuscript, copied in the sixth or seventh century, containing a letter written by a man named Mara bar Serapion to his son, Serapion. It was first published in 1855 by the English scholar William Cureton (Cureton 1855). Mara, apparently a Stoic philosopher from the city of Samosata on the Euphrates, writes from captivity, urging his son to pursue wisdom, and reflecting on the fate of wise men who were persecuted:

What advantage did the Athenians gain from putting Socrates to death? Famine and plague came upon them as a judgment for their crime. What advantage did the men of Samos gain from burning Pythagoras? In a moment their land was covered with sand. What advantage did the Jews gain from executing their wise king? It was just after that that their kingdom was abolished. God justly avenged these three wise men… Nor did the wise king die for good; he lived on in the teaching which he had given.

— Mara bar Serapion, Letter to his Son (author’s rendering, after Cureton)

The letter is usually dated to some time after AD 73, since it seems to refer to the destruction of Jerusalem and the scattering of the Jews as recent events, though some scholars date it later.

Mara does not name the “wise king,” but most scholars believe he is referring to Jesus. Who else was a “king” executed by the Jews, whose death was followed shortly after by the abolition of the Jewish kingdom (in AD 70), and whose teaching lived on after him? The title “King of the Jews” was nailed to Jesus’ cross (John 19:19). Mara was clearly not a Christian: he places Jesus alongside Socrates and Pythagoras as a wise teacher, says nothing of his resurrection or divinity, and blames his death on “the Jews” rather than on Pilate. That is exactly what makes his testimony valuable. It shows a pagan philosopher of the late first or second century who regarded Jesus as a real historical figure, a wise man unjustly put to death, whose teaching had survived him.

Lucian of Samosata: The Satirist

Lucian of Samosata (c. AD 125–after 180) was one of the most brilliant satirists of the ancient world, and he had a sharp eye for human folly. In The Passing of Peregrinus, written around AD 165, he mocks a charlatan philosopher named Peregrinus, who for a time joined the Christians, exploited their generosity, and rose to a position of leadership among them. Along the way Lucian describes the Christians with amused contempt:

The Christians, you know, worship a man to this day — the distinguished personage who introduced their novel rites, and was crucified on that account… You see, these misguided creatures start with the general conviction that they are immortal for all time, which explains the contempt of death and voluntary self-devotion which are so common among them; and then it was impressed on them by their original lawgiver that they are all brothers, from the moment that they are converted, and deny the gods of Greece, and worship the crucified sage, and live after his laws.

— Lucian, The Passing of Peregrinus 11, 13 (Fowler translation)

Lucian’s testimony is late, but it is entirely independent of Christian sources and thoroughly hostile. He confirms that Christians worshipped a man who had been crucified for introducing new religious practices; that they regarded him as their lawgiver; that they believed in immortality and were unafraid of death; that they considered one another brothers; that they rejected the Greek gods; and that they lived by his laws.

Celsus: The First Great Critic

The first comprehensive attack on Christianity by a pagan intellectual was written around AD 175–180 by a philosopher named Celsus, under the title The True Word. Celsus’s work has not survived independently, but around AD 248 the Christian scholar Origen wrote a detailed reply, Against Celsus, in which he quoted large portions of it. It is therefore possible to reconstruct much of what Celsus said.

Celsus was a learned and hostile critic who had studied the Christians’ writings closely. Significantly, he never suggested that Jesus did not exist. On the contrary, he took Jesus’ existence for granted and attacked the Christian account of him at every point. He claimed that Jesus had been born in a Jewish village to a poor woman who was divorced by her husband for adultery, and that his real father was a Roman soldier named Panthera (Against Celsus 1.28, 1.32). He claimed that Jesus had worked as a hired labourer in Egypt, where he learned magical powers, and that on returning to his own country he used these powers to proclaim himself a god (1.28, 1.38). He mocked Jesus for gathering around himself “ten or eleven persons of notorious character, the very wickedest of tax-gatherers and sailors” (1.62). And he ridiculed the idea that a man who was arrested, abandoned by his followers, and crucified could be divine.

Celsus’s attack is a backhanded confirmation of the Gospel story. His slander about Jesus’ birth presupposes that Christians were proclaiming that Jesus had been born in unusual circumstances — the virgin birth. His claim about Egypt echoes Matthew’s account of the flight into Egypt. His accusation of sorcery presupposes that Jesus was widely known to have performed extraordinary deeds; Celsus does not deny the deeds, he only attributes them to magic. His sneer about tax-gatherers and sailors confirms that Jesus’ disciples included people like Matthew the tax collector and the fishermen of Galilee. And his mockery of a crucified god confirms the central Christian claim that Jesus died on a cross. A second-century critic who had every reason to deny Jesus’ existence, if he could, chose instead to attack his character.

An Appeal to Roman Records

It is worth mentioning, finally, that early Christian writers addressing Roman officials appealed confidently to Roman records as confirming the facts about Jesus. Justin Martyr, writing his First Apology to the Emperor Antoninus Pius around AD 155, describes the crucifixion and miracles of Jesus and adds: “And that these things did happen, you can ascertain from the Acts of Pontius Pilate” (First Apology 35; compare 48). Tertullian, writing around AD 197, makes similar claims (Apology 5, 21).

We do not know what records Justin had in mind, and no official Roman report from Pilate survives. (Several later documents claiming to be Pilate’s reports, such as the Acts of Pilate that became part of the Gospel of Nicodemus, are generally regarded as Christian compositions of the fourth century or later.) The appeal should therefore be treated with caution. But it does show that early Christians, writing openly to the emperor himself, were confident enough in the historical facts to invite him to check his own records.

What the Outside Witnesses Tell Us

Let us gather the threads. From sources outside the New Testament — Jewish, Roman, Greek, and Syrian, nearly all of them indifferent or hostile to Christianity — we can establish the following:

  1. Jesus lived in Judea in the early first century, in the time of the Emperor Tiberius and the governor Pontius Pilate (Josephus, Tacitus).
  2. He was known as a wise man and teacher (Josephus, Mara bar Serapion, Lucian).
  3. He was reputed to perform extraordinary deeds, which his opponents attributed to sorcery (Josephus, Celsus; and, as we shall see in the next chapter, the Babylonian Talmud).
  4. He attracted followers among both Jews and Gentiles (Josephus).
  5. He had a brother named James, who was executed in Jerusalem in AD 62 (Josephus).
  6. He was called “Christ,” the Messiah (Josephus, Tacitus, Suetonius, Pliny).
  7. He was condemned to death by Pontius Pilate at the instigation of Jewish leaders, and crucified (Josephus, Tacitus, Lucian, Mara bar Serapion).
  8. Darkness was reported at the time of his death, which pagan writers tried to explain as an eclipse (Thallus and Phlegon, as reported by Africanus and Origen).
  9. His followers did not abandon him after his death, and reported that he had appeared to them alive (Josephus, especially in the Arabic version).
  10. His movement, apparently checked by his death, broke out again and spread rapidly — to Rome by the AD 40s and 60s, and through the cities and countryside of Asia Minor by the early second century (Suetonius, Tacitus, Pliny).
  11. His followers worshipped him “as a god,” met on a fixed day before dawn, sang hymns to him, lived by high moral standards, regarded one another as brothers, and were willing to die rather than deny him (Pliny, Tacitus, Lucian).

This is a remarkable body of evidence for a man who was, from the perspective of the Roman Empire, an obscure provincial teacher from a despised corner of the world, executed as a criminal after a public career of perhaps three years. Most people in the ancient world, even important people, left no trace in the historical record at all. Yet within a century of his death, Jesus of Nazareth was mentioned by the leading Jewish historian of the age, by the greatest Roman historian, by a Roman provincial governor in correspondence with the emperor, by an imperial secretary with access to the archives, by a Syrian philosopher, by the most popular satirist of the day, and by the first great intellectual critic of Christianity.

The Verdict of Scholarship

In the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, a few writers — notably the German scholars Bruno Bauer and Arthur Drews — argued that Jesus had never existed and that the Christian story was a myth constructed from earlier religious ideas. This “Christ myth theory” has been revived in recent years by a small number of writers, mostly outside the academic study of the ancient world.

The theory has been firmly rejected by the overwhelming majority of historians, including many who are not Christians. The classical historian Michael Grant, who wrote a historian’s study of Jesus without any commitment to Christian faith, concluded that modern critical methods fail to support the Christ-myth theory (Grant 1977). The late Maurice Casey, a scholar of early Judaism and Christianity who was not a believer, wrote an entire book refuting the arguments of the mythicists (Casey 2014). And Bart Ehrman — an agnostic, and a well-known critic of traditional Christian beliefs — wrote Did Jesus Exist? specifically to answer the mythicist claim. His answer is an unequivocal yes. Ehrman points out that the existence of Jesus is held by virtually every expert in the field, Christian or not, and that the evidence for it — including multiple independent sources within a few decades of his life, Paul’s personal acquaintance with Jesus’ brother James and his disciple Peter, and the testimony of Josephus and Tacitus — is far stronger than for most figures of the ancient world (Ehrman 2012).

The question of whether Jesus existed is therefore not seriously in doubt among historians. The real questions — the ones that matter most — are about who he was, what he did, and what happened after his death. On those questions, the outside sources take us a long way, but they cannot take us all the way. For that, we must turn to the most detailed sources of all: the Gospels and the other writings of the New Testament. Before we do, however, we will look at one further group of outside witnesses — the way Jesus is remembered in the writings of other religious traditions.

Cover of Does Jesus Exist? by Riekus Van Der Westhuizen: an open tomb glowing with light under a night sky.
Keep reading

The story continues.

Did he live? Did he die? Did he rise? Get the whole book from €9.99.